Same House, Different Stories

How siblings experience childhood differently

Recently I had one of those rare, quiet conversations with my sister – the kind that sneaks up on you and leaves you thinking for days. She posed a question that resonated deeply with me when I was in treatment – “How can two people grow up under the same roof and come away with such different stories?”  A question that I grappled with throughout my time in therapy.

We started talking about our childhood, casually at first, but slowly we drifted into deeper waters. It struck me how differently we each remembered the same home, the same parents, the same years.

I was reminded of conversations that I had with my therapist while in treatment, and shared with my sister some of the key takeaways from my counselors. Much of who we are today was shaped not just by what we experienced, but by how we each experienced it. Sure, our parents were the same people, but they weren't always the same parents to each of us.  Moreover, kids interpret events differently based on innate individual temperament, needs, or sensitivity. My twins are living proof of that!

On the surface, it’s easy to assume siblings share the same childhood. Same house. Same rules. Same parents. But that’s the illusion – the idea that a shared environment creates identical experiences. In reality, childhood is as personal as our fingerprints. Each of us grows up in a version of the family shaped by our position in it, our needs, our temperaments, and even the unspoken expectations placed on us.

Understanding who we are often starts with our early experiences, particularly those shaped by caregivers. When reflecting on your upbringing, it is natural to feel a mix of emotions towards your parents or guardians. It’s important to recognize that they, too, were shaped by their own experiences and challenges. The love they offered, however imperfect, was often their best attempt to guide us.

My sister and I grew up with the same caregivers, but we were not cared for in the same way. Not out of neglect or favoritism, but simply because our parents were different people at different times – younger vs older, more stressed vs more patient, more overwhelmed vs more settled. Not to mention, the state and health of their own relationship also varied within that time. The timing of parental dynamics and their emotional or financial capacity during certain years can drastically affect a child's formative experience.

As boomers, marrying your high school sweetheart and starting a family were the norm. While, as Gen x-ers, my sister and I didn’t marry until our thirties or have kids until many years later. A full decade and a half, after our parents.

It’s hard for me to compare myself at 20 versus me at 35. Of course I was the same person but my life experience and circumstances were vastly different. So when I compare my own experience of parenting my girls with the added stress and expectations of my parents generation during a wartime draft, I can’t help but feel sympathetic.

Beyond which, we were very different kids, requiring completely different things from them.

She reminded me of how emotional and volatile I was as a kid.  While I have no recollection of that 😉 I recognized the parallels to both of my parents. My mother was extremely sensitive, weeping without even realizing. My father was extremely volatile from 0 to 60 in 2.2 seconds. As a child, I unwittingly learned to incorporate the behavior they modeled and when confronted with situations where I was unhappy, or my needs were unmet I would have a “temper tantrum”.  Crying, screaming and carrying on, for what seemed like an eternity.

Likewise, I reminded her of how distant, cold and unapproachable she was to me as a kid.  While she may have taken the brunt of my parents more precarious years, being 5 years my elder, she turned her personal grievances with them into a resentment of me. She created distance with me as a means of exercising her frustrations with the expectations placed on her by my parents. Yet whenever she wanted something from them, she would enlist me to ask, so as not to draw their response, knowing full well how desperately I wanted her friendship and approval.

Similarly, we have different relationships and experiences with our extended family members. As an elder in our group of “cousins” she held a very different position. She was loved, respected, admired by all of us, and deservedly so. The sisterly bond she shares with many of our relatives developed in direct contrast to our relationship. Almost as if to counter the void that she felt for the nonexistent connection with me. And the age difference between us created a disparity that took decades to bridge.

While for myself, having idolized her from my very first day on this rollercoaster, and internalizing my differences from her as deficiencies within myself, helped form a narrative that I unwittingly yet genuinely believed. The maladaptive coping mechanisms that developed, such as: learning to isolate so as not to be revealed as being flawed, or punishing and berating myself behind closed doors, remain as defaults that I continue to work at, and probably always will.

As we reflect on our childhood, we may uncover feelings of hurt or disappointment concerning our caregivers. It can be easy to blame them for our pain or unmet expectations. Yet, when we take a step back and consider the pressures and demands they faced, we might start to see them in a more compassionate light – at least that is what I hope for my own children.

Our primary caregivers had their own dreams, fears, and backgrounds that shaped their decisions. Acknowledging their humanity allows us to release the weight of resentment we may carry, and gently nudges us toward healing, enabling us to redefine our relationship with our own history. This transformation doesn’t erase our feelings but rather shifts our perspective, allowing us to grow beyond our past.

The journey to understanding ourselves involves accepting both the good and the challenging moments from our upbringing. Every experience with our primary caregivers has a role in shaping who we become. Instead of focusing solely on what was lacking, we can choose to recognize the lessons learned from those experiences. Perhaps they taught us resilience, compassion, or the importance of seeking support. By valuing these lessons, we turn our narratives into stories of growth. We begin to see that while our caregivers may not have been perfect, their influence has also given us tools to navigate our own lives.

Ultimately, finding a balance between understanding ourselves and acknowledging the complexity of our caregivers can be a delicate process. It often involves digging deep to confront our emotions honestly. Sometimes, this means allowing ourselves to feel hurt before healing. It’s okay to accept that things weren’t perfect, as that’s a part of life’s journey.

There is no such thing as a perfect life. As human beings we all make mistakes and we are all scarred. How we choose to deal with those mistakes and scars can either weigh us down or become the very things that shape us into stronger, wiser, more compassionate people.  What truly matters is that we never stop growing and moving forward with grace and intention.

Talking about the differences in our childhood, openly and honestly helped my sister and I to understand and empathize with one another, with our younger selves, and parents too. Revisiting childhood memories, especially with those who shared in them can be profoundly healing. I hope that you can make space within your own family to explore and understand the complex yet beautiful journey of how you became who you are.

Sign up for my newsletter to get more content like this delivered straight to your inbox! Subscribe  

I'd love to hear from you! Please leave any questions, comments, or insights in the comments section below.